Sorry if it's been done, but I'm venturing forth to bigger better worlds by seeking out new categories of the asylum.
I was thinking about how often I've been copping out of renting movies. Then I had the urge to get one, but I'm just too tired. In any case, I was thinking about what movie I would rent (I knew it would have to be an "older" one). These are which came to mind:
Old twilight zone episodes
almost any old horror movie (we're talking 50s though)