MstrG
The Talamasca
Registered: Jul 2000
Location: Upstate NY
Posts: 10152 |
quote: Originally posted by Spooky:
...by stepping down Gore can make an effort to push for electoral reform of a heavily antiquated system that really has no place in 21st Centruy politics.
There are several things I could jump on here, but this seems to be a recurring theme in recent posts. I don't agree the Electoral College is a tool of the left. What the opponents and critics fail to accept in this argument is: the electoral system strikes a beautiful balance between pure democracy (where a significant voting bloc could potentially hijack an election, much more a left-leaning possibility), and a fractured republic, where each of the "nation-states" acts independently and carries equal weight. That states have should have some identity and autonomy is clear in the US Constitution and the Federalist Papers. The Electoral College provides for this, while still lending credence to the people as the jurors. And of course, you can see this system employed in the legislative arm of the government as well.
When you look at the now infamous "red and blue" map showing the breakdown of counties voting for president in the last election, you can see what will happen if this system is eliminated. Highly populous, mostly urban areas, which comprise about 50% of the US population, will wield an inordinate amount of power. 60% of the states, and more than 2/3 of the counties within them, voted against the popular vote winner, Gore.
Direct democracy is not what our framers intended; this is a representative Republic. And for that reason, the rhetoric about "a mandate from the people" should be eliminated from the current debate. I understand the practical reality of governing a nation split down the middle, but that only further illustrates why the state's powers to self-govern should never be overlooked or obstructed.
Gore doing a kamikaze would only further demonstrate the constant victimization stance taken by the left, and tag him with the loser label. In an interview broadcast this morning, Gore, in fact, said he would graciously accept defeat if and when it came, and work to make sure the transition to a Bush administration was a smooth one.
------------------------
SETI@Home: join us!
[This message has been edited by MstrG (edited 11-29-2000).]
Report this post to a moderator |
IP: Logged
|