Paint CHiPs
Viva Le Me
Registered: Jul 2000
Location: Location Location
Posts: 26420 |
quote: Originally posted by CHiPsJr
Yeah, it's a piss-poor case. It's akin to saying "Without a workforce which will do their bidding, people's liberty is restricted by the scope of their own individual abilities; hence, true Libertarianism entitles me to own slaves."
Well, it's certainly not internally consistent, if that's what you mean, but then again The Libertarian Republican was never that either, but I wouldn't say he did more harm than good (though ultimately he became irrelevent) or didn't exist.
I'm less concerned with litmus testing it though (not that, btw, yours isn't a point well worth taking); what is interesting, to me, is the matter of emphasis, and that, it seems to me, is for real. There are centrist Dems in the Lieberman/Warner/Clinton/Biden vein, and that's one thing (though I'd argue that Lieberman is less centrist than syncophant, but that's another argument). And then there are Democrats like Schwietzer, Feingold, and a handful of others, which are starting to become a new breed. I think, on this, kos has it right. I've said before that in my opinion, if the Democrats find a new, powerful voice (big "if"), it will be along one of two lines. Grassroots unapologetic progressivism of the Howard Dean/Gore 2.0/Air America variety, or firebrand Libertarian-emphasis populism, of the Schweitzer/Feingold vien. Kos, in his work, that post, and the upcoming book he mentioned, seems to me to be throwing in with the former--which is good, if you ask me. The Democratic base could do far worse than throwing in with the Schweitzers of the world. And, even if that doesn't manifest itself right away (Feingold 08!), I will be well pleased if control of the Democratic party is gradually wrestled away from the Kerrys, Clintons, and Pelosis and starts falling to the Feingolds, Reids, Schweitzers, etc. That will be a good sign for the Democrats, a bad sign for the Republicans (or maybe a good sign, in the long run, if the Dems start picking up the Perot independents and Libertarian moderates and the Republicans are forced to sit and stew with the Dobsons and DeLays and Schiavos and FMAs), and a good direction for the country, if you ask me.
__________________

Report this post to a moderator |
IP: Logged
|